Yesterday I had the opportunity to talk to some former students who are now seniors in high school. After the ceremony honoring them (that’s another story), the young men came into the library to talk to me, and a simple conversation about school evolved into an educational policy discussion.
First, they told me about their “silent” library. They laughed as they told me how they can’t talk in the library, and are threatened with demerits if they do. “It’s different than here,” they said. (I never was known for a quiet library). I have always tried to encourage discussion and sharing, and have tried to make the library a fun space that students would be happy to come to and stay in. After all, in a student’s world where social learning and exchange is commonplace and constant, imposing silence seems not only artificial but stifling. We have to encourage enthusiasm and collaboration. And that sometimes results in more noise than most find acceptable, and may look a little chaotic, but it seems to work.
We talked about past lessons and research, and how I had changed things to incorporate some newer tools like our class wikis, twitter, googledocs, and wallwisher. All our middle school students have gmail accounts that they use to login to other sites and to communicate with the faculty. I don’t think of any of these things as revolutionary; conversely, I think they’re a pretty basic step into web 2.0 tools appropriate for students this age. If anything, I think we could be more progressive than this, and I’m working on incorporating more collaborative tools into their lessons. I thought my former students would laugh at their simplicity, but the reaction I got was quite different. My high schoolers look at each other in astonishment. It seems that social media tools and most types of communication are being blocked at their school. “They don’t trust us,” they said. They laughed as they told me that the school has a twitter account, but they’re blocked from reading the feed at school. “We can’t use any of that stuff” was the general comment.
That got me thinking — how are schools preparing students for the 21st century, if policy becomes more restrictive as the students get older? I always thought with maturity comes increased responsibility. Where have the benefits of social media gotten lost? Or perhaps, more scarily, why have they yet to be recognized? Who is driving the policy that is preventing young adults from using the tools they use now in every other facet of their lives, and will continue to use in the years ahead? It’s a little scary when middle school curriculum and policy is more progressive than high school policy. When 18-year-olds recognize the absurdity of a school’s blocking and filtering policy, what does that say about the educators who are perpetrating it? Out of the mouths of babes —